Futuristic and suggestive

As in the U.S., Musk is not prepared to simply accept this refusal in the EU. He argues that “Robotaxi” is a new, futuristic, and suggestive term that requires imagination to understand. According to the Tesla CEO, “The unusual and inventive neologism is not part of the common vocabulary of the relevant consumers, but a fanciful and futuristic name suggesting technological innovation and modernity”.

Robotaxi Robovan
Links Robotaxi, Rechts Robovan. Bron: https://www.tesla.com/we-robot

Sum of its parts

One can almost imagine EUIPO thinking: what a word salad. Let’s keep it simple—“Robotaxi” is nothing more than the sum of its parts, namely “Robot” and “Taxi,” according to EUIPO. It is a word with a clear meaning that requires no interpretative effort from the consumer. Moreover, “robotaxi” appears in various English and German dictionaries. Therefore, it lacks distinctive character and will not be perceived by consumers as a trademark, EUIPO concluded.

Cyberbus accepted

But how can that be? Musk reportedly continues. You previously accepted our trademarks ‘Cybertruck’ and ‘Cyberbus.’ Why not ‘Robotaxi’? The European Trademark Office often hears such comparisons after refusing an application. But EUIPO responds with the same arguments each time: the registrability of a sign as an EUTM must be assessed solely on the basis of the EUTMR, as interpreted by the EU judicature, and not on the basis of previous Office practice. And in any event, these are different marks, so the cases are not comparable. Case closed.

Cybertruck

Appeal

Musk has until 4 April to appeal the decision. Knowing Musk, he will undoubtedly do so. But no matter how much time and money he throws at it, it is hard to imagine that he will prevail on appeal.

Bas Kist

 

Image Cybertruck: Photo by Maxim on Unsplash

Banner image: Photo by Maxim on Unsplash